All of the links contain true crime and/or creepy content. Please use discretion when viewing.
I despise when true crime content creators use humor so all of the links that deal with real crime and victims are made by those who take crime and its victims seriously. There's also A LOT of very popular sources not listed here, but this is a list of content that I like, well known or not.
True Crime Podcasts
A great place to get quick reviews on hundreds of true crime podcasts.
Also on Youtube.
Canadian True Crime
Into the Dark
All Crime No Cattle
They Walk Among Us
Once Upon a Crime
True Crime Garage
Women and Crime
Forty-Eight Hours Podcast
True Crime All the Time
/ True Crime All the Time Unsolved
Let's Talk About Sects
True Crime Campfire
You're Wrong About
Not 100% true crime related but has some stories dealing with crime. The DC Sniper episodes were a great listen.
True Crime Youtube Channels
I like this channel a lot, but many people have a problem with the narrator's voice. If it's grating to you, try setting the speed to 1.5x.
David Oranchak's Youtube Channel
One of the people behind the recent decoding of the Zodiac Killer's 403 code!
JCS - Criminal Psychology
Has a second channel as well.
Matt Orchard - Crime and Society
Claims to be a "Jim Can't Swim rip-off" but I personally enjoy his videos more. More commentary and custom content and way less unedited interrogation videos that go on forever.
The titles for some videos may seem "clickbait-y" but the majority of these videos have solid content.
Just discovered this channel and I'm very shocked that it's not more popular! Great narration, uses news clips and covers quite a few lesser known cases.
Youtube Channels That Cover A Variety of Eerie Topics
One of my favorite channels on Youtube, period. Extremely well done videos that cover a variety of bizarre topics. All of her content is worth viewing and I get excited whenever I see a new video of her in my feed. :)
Home to the famous "Down the Rabbit Hole" videos.
Inside A Mind
A new robot voice every video!
Mostly iceberg videos.
Creepypasta and ARGs
Ted the Caver
Often quoted as the "first creepypasta ever". It's a great read and very chilling but ends abruptly.
Ted the Caver - Full Story
The full story in case the original site goes down.
Ted the Caver - The Dark Somnium
A very well done reading of the creepypasta. Now with spooky ambient sounds!
Godzilla NES Creepypasta
Written by Cosbydaf in 2011, it's widely known for being one of the most fleshed out and creative creepypasta ever. Lots of contention on the quality of the ending, however. (I personally wasn't fond on the way it ended but it's grown on me over the years.)
Godzilla NES Creepypasta - Fangame
A extremely well done fangame of the Godzilla creepypasta! Still in development but demos are available to download. Lots of extra features and the soundtrack is amazing.
Godzilla NES Creepypasta - Fangame Speedrun
When I first learned of the fangame, I immediately thought, "I hope someone speedruns that game" and lo and behold...
Pale Luna Creepypasta
I'm not big on creepypasta but this is a great example of a well written story that isn't over the top yet is still disturbing.
I loved Petscop and I had the experience of following it when it was being updated, which was thrilling (and was full of long waits). I highly recommend watching the series if you love anything involving spooky video games. It's a shame that it's not a real game!
Petscop Comprehensive Progress Document
A must read if you want (to attempt) to understand Petscop.
Petscop analysis videos.
IceMaster's Petscop Forensics
mmillion's Petscop Page
BEN Drowned - Creepypasta
HIGHLY recommend reading this and watching the attached videos before continuing the Jadusable saga. I remember reading the very first thread that was posted in /x/ when I was attending college and having nightmares about BEN. That was... fun.
Channel for the "BEN Drowned" videos and the following ARG, which ended this year. I couldn't follow what was going on in the ARG at all but there's no denying that the videos are extremely well made.
I hope this creepy video series is still being continued, it's so creative.
Other Websites with Creepy Content
The Lost Media Wiki
Lost Media Archive
Your Ghost Stories
End of the world scenarios.
Not really a creepy website, it's just very odd. However, it's always given me the creeps... probably just me.
Linda's Haunted Halloween
A Candy Rose
A true crime based website that focuses mostly on missing children.
136 Creepy Wikipedia Articles
Imgur Spooky Stash Links
Archived Links to the Tru TV Crime Library
True Crime, Mysteries and Catastrophes